The Bill of Rights has afforded the citizens the ability to address the government in matters which are a concern to us. As the sole support for all government services, is it wrong to question our government? The Bill of Rights says nay and nay and nay, again. As some would call it the writings of dusty old dead men, their wisdom is still valid today.
DATE: April 22, 2014
TO: Delaware County Commissioners
FROM: Tom Terry
RE: Apology to James Carmichael
I am challenging you as Commissioners to prove the data I gave you yesterday is false. I say the data shows the Delaware County Taxpayers have been duped out of approximately $508,000. Two years at $254,000. You are the Auditors of Delaware County; responsible for receiving bids, authorizing claims, and safeguarding our funds, IC 36-2-6-2. You have been shown that the services for this contract have been drastically reduced with no reduction in cost to the taxpayers. It is my belief that you have not personally looked the facts over but relied on others who have a political agenda. I am asking you to go to work; look this material over, ask questions, seek advice, and look the material over again. Ask your attorney; ask a State attorney, prove me wrong.
If you prove me wrong, I will issue a formal apology at the next Commissioner’s meeting to James Carmichael. Consider this as a request to be placed on the agenda. Also, if found wrong, I will make a $5000 contribution to Carmichael’s campaign.
If I am right, the Delaware County Taxpayers will need your help to collect this massive overpayment and put safeguards in place to stop such a thing from happening again. Also, if found right, I want a full investigation of all expenditures coming from the Assessor’s office.
This is more than a challenge, it is your job. You should be able to investigate this contract in two days. If you need video copies of the Oct 1, 2012 Commissioner’s meeting or copies of any data I might have; just ask. I am sure you will find this challenge important, rewarding and a conclusion of many weeks of listening to me complain.
Copies of this challenge are going to the Delaware County Prosecutor, members of the County Council, the State Police, the State Board of Accounts, the Department of Local Government Finance, the Attorney General, the Muncie Star Press, Governor Pence and most importantly the Taxpayers of Delaware County.
You are in the driver’s seat. SHOW THE TAXPAYERS OF DELAWARE COUNTY HOW CONCERNED YOU REALLY ARE.
The First Amendment (Amendment I) to the United States Constitution prohibits the making of any law respecting an establishment of religion, impeding the free exercise of religion, abridging the freedom of speech, infringing on the freedom of the press, interfering with the right to peaceably assemble or prohibiting the petitioning for a governmental redress of grievances. It was adopted on December 15, 1791, as one of the ten amendments that constitute the Bill of Rights.
On April 14, Delaware County Treasurer, John Dorer, was arrested. Per the Muncie Star newspaper Dorer saw “47 criminal charges that accuse him of repeatedly mishandling, and in one instance stealing, county funds.” No one from the local level to the Indiana Statehouse can say with any certainty if money has been stolen on more than one occasion. The books are in such bad shape, it is impossible to follow the accounting records, making it easy to siphon off funds unnoticed.
As would be expected, varied opinions on his guilt or innocence appeared in the story chats. Some went as far as to say he was framed by the local Democrat Party. The Democrat Party may be in control in our little neck of the woods. Doubtful their power extends to the state government. Dorer is a Democrat, but divorced his affiliation from the Headquarters and instead ran on the Team Democrat “ticket”. He won in 2008 and again in 2012.
Rather than take the newspaper’s word as gospel, decided to head to the Indiana State Board of Accounts and read for myself the audit reports. Having read audits on the Muncie Sanitary District, City of Muncie, Muncie Public Schools and other various taxing units I gleaned quite a bit of information on the workings of Delaware County. One common theme seems to be the same mistakes are repeated again and again. You’ll find the audits below:
John Dorer is responsible for his actions and should he be found guilty will need to be accountable to the State of Indiana and finally the taxpayers of Delaware County. The treasurer is the start of the financial chain and may even possibly be the leading cause to Delaware County’s fiscal woes. The Treasurer’s Department prepares the financial information and submits it to the Auditor’s Office, which in turn disseminates the fiscal information to the County Council and County Commissioners. If the records are in such disarray from the start, then it’s obvious their decisions are based on faulty accounting. That’s a problem, folks.
Who’s minding the store?
At the close of every audit, an exit interview is conducted by the State Board of Accounts with sundry elected officials attending. No action is taken by the elected officials to insure the violations are curbed, the same happens again the next year. Again and again. Public servants, elected, have ignored the audits while untold millions in taxpayer money slips into the abyss of shoddy management.
While we point our fingers and cluck our tongues at Dorer’s arrest, we refuse willingly or out of ignorance to ask our elected officials what role did they play in all this? By their inaction, plenty. When they knock on your door, seeking your vote, gently ask of them “Who’s minding the store?”
If you have some time to kill, take a gander at other State Board of Accounts audits. Imagine allowing non-bonded employees to collect cash; employees paid cash without any paperwork; one cash drawer (City Clerk lost $13,000); no contracts for services rendered; $3,500,00.00 with no internal controls(2012 Redevelopment audit), etc, etc, etc.
“Governmental units should have internal controls in effect which provide reasonable assurance regarding the reliability of financial information and records, effectiveness and efficiency of operations, proper execution of management’s objectives, and compliance with laws and regulations. Among other things, segregation of duties, safeguarding controls over cash and all other assets and all forms of information processing are necessary for proper internal control. (Accounting and Uniform Compliance Guidelines Manual for Counties of Indiana, Chapter 1)”
The rumor has finally been put to rest. Did the City of Muncie Building Commissioner, Craig Nichols, get the remodeling contracts for the City of Muncie’s City Hall? This very rumor had been circulating for months, and finally a rumor that has truth attached. Yep, folks, he got it. In fact, other city projects, you know, the ones that have received city as well as State tax dollars may have his company written all over it.
Unfortunately, we won’t know how much his company made. That’s private.
Mr. Nichols signed a conflict of interest disclosure, so everything is O.K. I wonder, the person responsible for the construction code, as in the position of Building Commissioner, will cite his own company for violations? Or will it just be disguised as a change order, and payment submitted so the Advanced Walls & Ceilings won’t lose any money? I don’t believe the Board of Public Works will even consider questioning any bills from Mr. Nichols, the Building Commissioner a/k/a owner of Advanced Walls & Ceilings.
Advanced Walls and Ceilings Indiana Secretary of State information
Just last year, the attorney for Muncie Sanitary District, Mike Quirk, started a business and began collecting payment for services rendered. His business was filed with the State of Indiana several months later. As with Mr. Nichols, we have no idea if this is saving us money or costing us money. SOS
However, there is a bit of history which can help you determine if this is beneficial.
The County purchased a truck from a county’s highway employee’s son. Cash for Clunkers, Delaware County Style. I’m glad as a taxpayer, we could help a poor fella out of his upside down truck loan.
The county dog catcher resigned after the County animal control truck was stolen by a drunk neighbor. The ex-dog catcher later received a contract to roof a county building. The contract was rescinded and he threatened to sue the county. But, never fear, the City of Muncie, saved the day. How, you ask? Simple. Fire a company that did building debris clean-up and hire the ex-dog catcher. Problem solved.
Remember the rumor the previous mayor would fire anyone that disagreed with her? MITS board member, Karl Kizer, felt it first hand. 25 years on the board, well-respected and knowledgeable had the audacity to question the mayor. Out he went. Oh, this was done by the current mayor.
Does anyone remember Culpepper insurance? If you don’t, being a big Democrat party supporter, the commissioners hired the company to take care of the county’s insurance. Boy did he, as costs skyrocketed out of control. 2003 mayoral candidate Dennis Tyler said there was no place for Culpepper in his administration. Tyler won in 2011 and take a guess who showed up to offer us insurance? No word if he saved us money on our liability policy.
We take care of our own here. We’re loyal like that.
What a fiasco when the commissioners tried to pass an ordinance limiting the area that Center Township Fire could service. Kind of like if your house is located in Muncie but closer to CTFD station, they were not allowed to go put the fire out. Oops, some 911 calls got misrouted, too.
Friendships and loyalty run deep here. In fact, it is the backbone of our very existence. Take for example, when the Democrat Chair was being indicted for forging papers to remove a candidate from the ballot. The chair, Phil Nichols, resigned and appointed Dennis Tyler, the now current mayor. Mr Tyler then appointed Phil Nichols to the election board. Let nothing like an indictment stand in the way of a friendship.
Time doesn’t allow for everything in complete detail, as that would really take a book. But consider these things:
The Fair Board ordinance requires an even number of members from both parties. This didn’t happen so solving the problem was simply rewrite the ordinances to match the appointments.
The Justice Center which was filled to the brim with party favorites, made national news and cost a pretty penny for the taxpayers.
Royerton Sewer, again a board filled with wives of party members, cost the taxpayers some dough. And it hasn’t stopped costing the residents.
Rep. Trey Gowdy, R-S.C., sponsor of the ENFORCE the Law Act. I caught this on CSpan yesterday and found the clip.
LOIT comin’ back?
Here we go again, an opportunity for Muncie City Council to open back up the LOIT debate. This time we can be taxed for public transportation throughout the county.
In 2009, if you will recall, Muncie City Council held a public hearing to pass a tax on every working person regardless if you lived in the city or county. It never got passed, and I don’t believe it was ever tabled. Somewhere in the abyss it’s still festering. This time though, Indiana wants to use it for transportation.
At least, voters will have a say instead of allowing nine people to make the decision. The majority of which salivate over any tax increase, where spending millions delights and barely blink an eye at increasing city tax levies. The majority increased the Muncie City tax levy and the budget, County was looking at passing Cumulative Capital Development (CCD tax). They also came out in support of $45 million tax increase and finally in ’09 the love for the Wheel Tax came to fruition.
LOIT was their baby, too.
Muncie City Council ignored the budget for nearly two years, and what is the first thing when realizing there is a fiscal problem? Why increase your taxes, of course. Last year the city ended with over $8 million balance and a tax increase. Proof any time is a good time for more taxes with the majority of Democrats in office.
Provides for the establishment or expansion of public transportation services in an eligible county through local public questions placed on the ballot under ordinances adopted by the fiscal body of the eligible county. Provides that Delaware County, Hamilton County, Hancock County, Johnson County, Madison County, and Marion County are eligible counties. Authorizes eligible counties to fund approved public transportation projects through various parts of the local option income tax rates that are available under current law for other purposes and by imposing on C corporations a county income tax or a county employment tax. Specifies that fares must cover 25% of the operating costs of a transportation system established or expanded under the bill. Authorizes interlocal agreements, public-private partnerships, and bonding with respect to a public transportation project. Provides that if a transportation project is approved in an eligible county, transportation services must be provided through the transportation project throughout the eligible county and must be made available under this article to all citizens of the county. Prohibits a political subdivision from using public funds to promote a position on a local public question regarding transit. Prohibits an eligible county from carrying out a light rail project. Provides that in the case of a public transportation corporation in an eligible county that has approved a local public question, labor agreements may provide for the nonbinding mediation of salaries, wages, and salary and wage related fringe benefits, including accident, sickness, health, dental, vision, life, disability, retirement benefits, and paid time off. Provides that the provisions in the bill do not create a moral obligation of the state.
Click on the Indiana General Assembly for SB176 and 2014 Session.
We have been reading a lot about the state of education in this country. From Common Core curriculum to school vouchers. Muncie Community Schools is seeing a complete change over from closing schools, to bus waivers. A few days ago, the local newspaper published an “Our View: Voucher system creating two education classes“. In all honesty, I very seldom read the paper’s “Our View” yet this title sparked my interest.
I like to feel the pulse of what local citizens think about a particular subject. Although , very seldom surprised by the comments, read with interest their obvious dislike for any change in the education system outside of the “how it’s always been run”. They all seem to be big on “choice”, only it must be their choice, not your choice. Most did not favor the parent’s right to choose and definitely against any tax dollars going to “private” schools. Never mind we have been financing the 21st Century Scholars, PELL grants, GI Bill and the like, for decades. Continue reading →
See you in Belize….
If you care to read the ruling from Indiana Department of Education, you may find it here.
Muncie Community Schools has some daunting issues and no plans on how those will be addressed. No plan for transportation and possibly no cost savings for the high school consolidation or closing.
Muncie Community School’s waiver request was denied by the Indiana Department of Education (IDOE).
IDOE says the waiver was denied because the district’s plan was “insufficient and fails to demonstrate that Muncie has formulated a sufficient plan that provides for the safe movement of eligible students to and from school,” as required.
Muncie Star Press 1-11-14
We weathered (pardon the pun) a snowstorm. A major casualty when a snowplow caught fire. A total loss to a county with no money. and with hopes to recoup the loss with outside funds. The driver escaped injury, and that is definitely something to rejoice over. The next big weather event will be flooding. Can’t wait.
None of us will be looking forward to the utility bills. This storm is going to be expensive for everyone.
The filing season has begun and will continue until February 7th. As expected, some of the old gals and guys will be looking to continue their tenure or switch positions. Mayor Tyler and his crew were ecstatic in 2011 all of his good friends were now controlling both city and county. No excuses, he said. There are, though. It’s not their fault, it’s yours. The judicial race is pretty much sewn up for me.
Another big event is watching the Muncie Sanitary District as they slowly slide into the $168 million storm water project. Removing Steve Murphy from the board and replacing him with Joe Evans was a major turning point. Joe was an intricate player in the Royerton Sewer Fiasco and so one must entrust him to a project 168 times more expensive. My prediction is: you will be paying a lot more.
No matter where you choose to live, you just can’t get away from the crew. Although we looked for homes in Royerton, the expensive sewer bills deterred us. Neighboring county, Hamilton, is looking like a good place to retire in 10 years. Talk about progress.
We live in a strange little area. While we constantly talk about bridging the gap between town and gown, as soon as a gown addresses the town all bets are off the table.
Yesterday, a local economist Dr. Cecil Bohanon, (one of my favorites) wrote another column. This one titled Why Politics is so Nasty is really a non-partisan look at our current political climate. Many good points made and the one which resonated with me “it is so much more fun to be entertained than to have to think through a serious argument.”
Fortunately, one doesn’t need to travel far for entertainment.
“Of course one of the big problems he ignored was the amount of money ij politics today and Cecil is a fully owned subsidiary of the Koch brothers. ” wrote a local poster in the newspaper chat section. The person attached a link to PDF document as proof, I suppose. 30+ pages of grant information complete with graphics. I’m sure many took the time to read it. Not.
I had read the document earlier, so I just skimmed through the pages. Yep, the dude was right. Dr. Bohanon received a $2,000 grant from…drum roll, please…
Charles Koch Foundation
All the proof one needs right there in black & white. Perhaps the informed poster was first alerted to the connection from reading the Muncie Squeak.
Have a nice weekend, y’all.